The Official Jameson Cigar Review Thread

[King Catfish]

KC

That's a very good review on the Jameson Robusto. I wish I could have said the same about the Torpedo. You would think that the two would be nearly identical at least in flavors.
What if I send you my remaining Torpedo to review as a comparison? Would you compare it to the Robusto's? I'd really like to give the Jameson's a fair shake.

Have a good weekend.

I certainly would. I'll trade you for a robusto if you like.

[King Catfish]

Well, I have received the Jameson short torpedo from Deedubya. Not one to waste postage, the fine gentleman used the opportunity to bomb me with some other tasty-looking sticks. DW, you're a Prince!

[King Catfish]

Deedubya send this one on to me for a comparison. I smoked it along with a pint of light-bodied pilsner beer.

This cigar is not much different from the robusto, I will reemphasize the dry, weak start and the nice finish. I found a little extra maltiness/muskiness in the middle.

Give this an 84, so the Jameson remains in the mid-80s, for me.

I will smoke another of the robustos in 2 weeks to see how the cigars have progressed in the humi.

[mrtr33]

I just pulled my first gift from Brad out of the humi the other night.

I agree with the majority of my comrades. Medium in body. Very accentuated tobacco tastes. Plenty of billowing smoke, and zero burn issues.

I found the spice attached to this cigar almost a bit too much.

Even so, I would plan on keeping a few around. Probably not to impress friends, but to have on an enjoyable summer afternoon somewhere.

[slcraiders]

Hey, anything with my name in it has to be good! I can't wait to try Brad's new lines.

[bigwhiteash]

I just got a sample of Brad's new Black label cigars. Very nice looking Churchill cigar. Can't wait to get behind this one!


I burned the red label you sent me Mark, very nice smoke IMO. Burned perfectly, lots of smoke, peppery and earthy. It dod get a little bitter near the end, but they're young. I would imagine that five or six months would put them right up there with some of the big names.