I would throw away the Criollo, then smoke the Italia (have a skewer on hand b/c they always seem to have a tight draw), then the Brazilia (nothing to write home about). I'm one of the weirdos that enjoys the Italia, but I only buy the box pressed as it usually provides a good draw. Ultimately, it's CAO, so who really cares? Though it is a step up from your Macacrapo Hampton Court