I've seen these reviews go on too long not to say something.
Look, I only participate in one cigar board. I have no idea what is going on in other boards, your history on other boards, or anything like that. But on this board, I notice that you post a lot of reviews. Specifically, video reviews. I'm sure that takes work, and time, and all that's great.
I don't have the capability to watch you smoke a cigar for however long it takes. It's not that my bandwidth or computer won't allow me, it's that there is no time in my day to watch a video review. Nor do I care to. I would read what you have to say way before I watch whatever you have to say. Furthermore, while you review some unique cigars, several of the reviews you have done can be found already on the board. I guess what I'm getting at is, you post too many redundant reviews. Look around the board; duplicate reviews usually tend to reference earlier reviews. I'm guilty of not doing this myself, but it provides perspective, and shows that you are contributing to the community. If it's something new, great. But it seems like reviewing cigars is what you like doing here. Maybe instead of littering the Review and/or Cigar forums with each individual review, maybe just post one thread - kaelaria's video cigar reviews - and post all of your reviews in that thread. That would be my suggestion. Take it or leave it. But from an objective point of view, it looks like you are just hawking your own blog.
Thanks for reading.






Reply With Quote
Bookmarks