I find that my palate is greatly affected by food, drink, medication, etc. I have found some sticks to be downright nasty only to try one some time later and enjoy it. Now don't get me wrong, there are some hopeless cigars (Thompson Manolete) that I will never like. So keeping meticulous records might actually be a self-defeating attempt at organization.

Or... you can start a review thread like the KC/DW world famous review thread and put it up there for all of us.