I would never be involved in a pass that he is a participant in. He put a damaged cigar in a pass and when it was brought to his attention, he tried to lie his way out of it and make excuses. The proper thing to do would have been to say "Ooooops, sorry, I'll make good on it." but what does Scotty do? NOTHING!!! What's worse is that it was his own brother-in-law's pass!

If he's going to treat his own brother-in-law like that do you think he'd be any different with others?

As far as box splits or trades, absolutely not. I would never have HIM send me cigar because I doubt he's smart enough or experienced enough to properly package them without them sustaining damage during shipping. Would I take his money and send him a fiver or halfa box of cigars? Again no, he's not the type of person I want to deal with.