Grading: 1st Third 2nd Third 3rd Third Overall
badwhale A A A A
buzz A B C B
craig A A A A
FightingFish B+ B B B
heftysmokes B+ B - B
kevin7 B+ B+ - B+
logan37 A- B A A-
Mangyrat A- A- A- A-
Mizicke5273 A A B+ A
mrtr33 A A A A
prophetic_joe B C D C
TheGreekTitan B B B B
VancouverMark A- A- A A
Average A- B+ B+ B+

Thoughts: Smoke Again Buy a Box Recommend
badwhale Definitely Yes Definitely
buzz Yes Yes Yes
craig Definitely Yes Definitely
FightingFish Maybe Probably not Maybe
heftysmokes Yes Probably not Maybe
kevin7 Yes Maybe Yes
logan37 Yes Maybe Yes
Mangyrat Yes Maybe Yes
Mizicke5273 Definitely Yes Yes
mrtr33 Yes Maybe Yes
prophetic_joe Probably not Definitely not Probably not
TheGreekTitan Yes Probably not Maybe
VancouverMark Definitely Yes Definitely

Last Words:
Quote Originally Posted by badwhale
10th anny.
Quote Originally Posted by buzz
I am going to buy a box of the rothschilds. This is a tasty cigar and worth dealing with the wrapper issues.
Quote Originally Posted by craig
Finally, my kind of cigar.
Quote Originally Posted by heftysmokes
Wish I could have finished this cigar. I honestly have no idea what it it (which makes me three for three!)
Quote Originally Posted by kevin7
Pretty nice cigar, no JdN Antano but still a pretty powerful cigar.
Quote Originally Posted by logan37
I think this is a Camacho 10th Anniversary. But I may have just shot myself in the foot.
Quote Originally Posted by Mangyrat
To me this was a good every day cigar.
Quote Originally Posted by Mizicke5273
This cigar really hit the spot and the Lagavulin went phenomenally with it! Really, another awesome cigar? Two in a row? I really hope I enjoy the final.....
Quote Originally Posted by mrtr33
Overall, I thought this was really good. I normally don't like ring gauges this large, and constructurally, I thought this cigar was a mess. But the taste was awesome, I loved the flavor profile throughout.
Quote Originally Posted by prophetic_joe
While I didn't have a good relationship with Irene I am still possibly willing, eventually, to give her another try however for now I think we need time apart.
Quote Originally Posted by TheGreekTitan
I liked Irene, but a bit of a one trick pony. Maybe I cut too much off the cap, the airy draw really detracted from the experience. That said, I would definitely give this stick another smoke given the opportunity.