Rate cigars you've recently smoked

**Drake** · 03-21-2005, 11:08 AM

I decided to start this thread because I think there are a lot of us that try cigars and don't post reviews because we're not so keen on the lingo. (like me

) so, just give it a rating of 1- 100.

good cigars I've recently smoked:

Montecristo platinum mini belicoso - 88

Ashton VSG Illusion - 90

Ashton VSG Tres Mystique - 86

Camacho corojo gigante - 89

**luke ford** · 03-22-2005, 02:54 AM

partagas black classico-85
puros indios piramide #2-87
padron 3000 maduro-88
partagas serie d no.4-88

**Yeagermeister** · 03-23-2005, 08:28 PM

Cohiba Robusto - my first one, and it was fantastic- 98
Bolivar corona - just finished smoking my first one an hour ago. Knocked me on my ass- 80
Ashon Aged Maduro no. 60 - What a fine smoke it is! - 90

**MMAB** · 03-23-2005, 08:51 PM

I must go out and get a few. Haven't had one in a while!

Recent discovery at a famous NH shop

IPO Miami "Torpedo" - 90 nice and sharp!

also... a forgotten treasure

RyJ Churchill "en tubo" (in tube) 95 (actually the whole "tubo" RyJ line is phenominal and proves that you can get a great cigar for $5)

Camacho SLR Toro - 88 - a headkicker - very nice
Gispert Churchill - 80 - really not bad for a $4 cigar!
Rocky Patel Sungrown - 90 - nice, spicy

**Drake** · 03-24-2005, 12:02 PM

Originally Posted by MMAB

I must go out and get a few. Haven't had one in a while!

Recent discovery at a famous NH shop

IPO Miami "Torpedo" - 90 nice and sharp!

also... a forgotten treasure

RyJ Churchill "en tubo" (in tube) 95 (actually the whole "tubo" RyJ line is phenominal and proves that you can get a great cigar for $5)

Camacho SLR Toro - 88 - a headkicker - very nice
Gispert Churchill - 80 - really not bad for a $4 cigar!
Rocky Patel Sungrown - 90 - nice, spicy

i just bout a Rocky Patel Sungrown yesterday. probably smoke it tonight

**Drake** · 04-01-2005, 10:11 AM

zino platinum shorty - 92

**MMAB** · 04-06-2005, 07:12 PM

Carlos Torano 1959 Silver - Grand Churchill - Excellent cigar - nice body - full flavored and smo-o-o-o-o-th! Tough to find locally at the moment though. Picked a few up while I was in Tampa. Damn! Should of bought a box!

Hey Drake! I just picked up a box of Rocky Patel's SG Toros! Mmmmmmm....mmmmm!!!!!

**flushh** · 04-06-2005, 08:43 PM

From this week:

CAO Italia Ciao, dark & spicy, 87
Macanudo Prince Philip Cafe Natural, always smooth, 90
Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur no. 1 Maduro, full bodied & rich, 90
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Churchill Natural, tasty & great draw, 91

flushh

**MMAB** · 04-10-2005, 04:46 PM

My best buddy was up visiting from FLA and we had a few RyJ Black Label Anniversario Torpedos. I had forgotten how good they are. That will be my next box purchase!

**MMAB** · 04-10-2005, 04:52 PM

Yeah.....I'd give em' a 90. But of course any rating is subjective.

Very smooth, slightly creamy, medium bodied. The classic RyJ "tartness" as I refer to it is mellowed with a little sweetness.

Excellent cigar.