I would not buy cigars from someone who doesn't seem to know anything about them. I like to buy from the people that are nice and helpful and willing to talk about cigars and educate me on what I am buying.
If you look hard hard enough and try enough different brands I am sure you are to stumble across a good price stick that tastes like a high dollar one, just depends on your taste though too I would think. But I am no expert myself and am new to this too so don't take anything I say as gospel. lol