I think everything depends on your personal taste for strength, etc

But I would not try the curly head as I don't thinkits a good representation of AF line at all
Exclibur sounds good
Baccarat is very mild and a unique mild at that -- not representative of a mild segment in general. Want a nice mild smoke get a Fonseca
Punch grand cru is ok but people either love or hate punch. Mild to medim try a CAO gold, Gispert, Gurhka vintage, H.Upmann
Oliva is a good cigar might want to compare the regular to he grand cameroon