I've not tried Buffalo Trace (I don't think my local shop has it) but if they do I'll grab a bottle. I like the usual suspects myself too, maker's, knob creek, etc.

Usually when I'm smoking cigars I'll have a jack and coke. I personally like Ridgemont Reserve also, and I don't think anyone has mentioned it during the thread:

http://www.bartonbrands.com/1792.html

I'm wanting to try the Havana Club Rum, but it's a little hard to find here in America and all.