I actually have been involved in two contests - where five different robusto's were given to each participant, and they were asked to identify the five cigars. Some were fairly easy because of the type of wrapper (corojo, for example) when not many existed. I actually was fooled because one was a Davidoff and I would have thought I would have picked it out easily - I didn't!!! I don't think it's going to be as easy as one would think...

That sounds like a great idea - but I also like the idea of doing one common ($3.00 range) vs. something a bit better (at least the $8 or more range) to see who can pick out the better cigar. The more thought that goes into what's sent out - the better....

I like your thinking!!!