Identifying Cigars By Look

[godfather]

So what would the consensus be? 1 cigar or 2. There would be a quicker turnover time if you only had to review one. You COULD still be reviewing a classic smoke or a toad (within certain reasonable parameters).
With 2 cigars, you have the advantage of knowing one of them is supposed to be better.

Also, would this be on the "review" section, or "exchange"?

Awesome idea Mazeman!!! I'm in!

My suggestion -

Get a list of participants. Everyone gets randomly assigned a 'buddy.' You and your 'assigned buddy' exchange 2 cigars each ...and let the games begin from there...

That way the interest is kept up and those of us in line don't have to impatiently wait to be called on :). It'd be fun to see everyone participate in something at the same time and I'm sure the posts will be pretty entertaining.

Group wide board VIRTUAL HERF baby!!!!