Help Me Choose!!!

[Stryprod]

Okay Folks, I have a great amount of variation of smokes in the humi and I am looking for direction on which cigar to smoke next out of my stock for a relaxing Friday night. I prefer medium bodied and lots of flavor, especially creamy taste (no jokes). An example of a smoke I enjoyed was the A.F. Short Story & also the ERDM Robusto Maduro. Here is a list of what I have so rock the vote but keep it to two out of the list!

5 Vegas – Churchill
5 Vegas Gold – Churchill
C.A.O. Black Lt. - Bengal
C.A.O. Brazilia – Gol!
C.A.O. Criollo – Pato
Carlos Torano Casa Torano – Toro
Carlos Torano Exodus 1959 – Toro
Carlos Torano Exodus Silver – Corona Grande
Carlos Torano Exodus Silver – Robusto Corto
Cusano 18 – Robusto
Don Kiki Green Label – Double Corona
El Rey Del Mundo – Robusto Suprema
Gurkha Ancient Warrior – Torpedo
Gurkha Master’s Select – Double Corona
Gurkha Regent – Toro
Natural by Drew Estate – Root
Padron – 2000
Pueblo Dominicano – Serie I Torpedo
Rocky Patel Sun Grown – Torpedo

[iluvmysh]

I would choose either the Gurkha Ancient Warrior or the ERDM and tell us how it goes.

[WOXOF]

Hmmm,
Ya cant go wrong with the Carlos Torano Exodus 1959. The Gurkha Ancient Warrior is good if you can keep it lit.

[Stryprod]

Hmmm,
Ya cant go wrong with the Carlos Torano Exodus 1959. The Gurkha Ancient Warrior is good if you can keep it lit.

What would be your description of the Ancient Warrior?

[WOXOF]

I've only had one and it was a while back. I can't really pick out flavors yet like some of the more experienced smokers. It was medium in strength with a good flavor to it. I had trouble keeping the burn going on mine. I was trying to read a book at the time so that got pretty anoying. You said you liked medium bodied, creamy cigars which is why I chose the Warrior. If I were to choose another cigar from the list regardless of the strength, I would go with the Brazilia.

[Newfie]

I've only had 5 or 6 of the exact cigars on your list, and I won't go by what I've heard or read, just on my experiences only:

I'd recommend the C.A.O. Brazilia – Gol! and the Cusano 18 – Robusto.

Both of those are high on my shopping list when I go to Richmond in 2 weeks!

Whatever you smoke, enjoy it!