I've only had one and it was a while back. I can't really pick out flavors yet like some of the more experienced smokers. It was medium in strength with a good flavor to it. I had trouble keeping the burn going on mine. I was trying to read a book at the time so that got pretty anoying. You said you liked medium bodied, creamy cigars which is why I chose the Warrior. If I were to choose another cigar from the list regardless of the strength, I would go with the Brazilia.