I noticed there aren't too many BOTL interested in Macanudos. Maybe that's why there hasn't been a response to this thread. Is it that bad of a cigar? My first cigars were Macanudos because they were well known and seem to be the best seller in the US. Not that bad a cigar, for a beginner. Don't know why it's shunned by Aficionados here.

Onyx Reserve is definitely far more superior to the Macanudo, but I definitely wouldn't ban Macanudos from my rotation.

I'm just gonna dig my hole and wait for the flaming for enjoying Macanudos.