Quote Originally Posted by chefchris View Post
ya, i just bought my first onyx reserves yesterday. got it sitting in the humi. intrested to know what others think about it.
-It's definitely better than Macanudo, but still a mild smoke.

Quote Originally Posted by nhcigarfan
smoke what you like. If you into the Maduros try a sancho panza double maduro. Smooth, sweet and tasty.
-Yeah, I like the flavor of maduro cigars. I'll try your recommendation in the near future. Thanks.

Quote Originally Posted by bigpoppapuff
nothing "onyx" excites me....an average maduro,at best...

try the camacho maduro
trilogy maduro
la aurora maduro (mmmmmm)
leon jimenes maduro........all of these,light years ahead of an onyx...
-BPP, would those be considered Medium to Full or all Full bodied cigars? Considering I'm coming from Macanudos and Onyx, I wouldn't want to skip to a full bodied cigar just of yet. THanks for the recommendation though, I'll keep those in my list for future rotations. May have to go to a B&M today and buy a stick of each.

Andrew