I feel so old and SO naive

[CoventryCat86]

All of the above plus environmental (I guess that falls under philosophical). It's actually very nice not having something that requires so much expense and maintenance. We've found there are more appropriate ways to travel. While a car is very convenient and fits most needs, it's also super expensive, even if the car is paid off: insurance, gas, oil, other maintenance, repairs, etc. We've been car ownership-free for almost a year now. We do all our shopping by bike and trailer, travel by bike and occasionally bus, and have rented a car once. We carpool when needed and chip in for gas.

Well, living in a college town (where Oregon State University is located) you can probably get away with that but the other 99.999% of America, it's pretty much impossible to survive without a car.

I've never financed a car in my life, I do all of my own repairs, I don't waste money on collision & comprehensive insurance. I drive fancy cars like Jaguars and top of the line Olds 98s but I buy them when they're ten to fifteen years old for pennies on the dollar from their original selling price. My car expenses are negligible compared to all of life's other expenses like housing, electricity, taxes, health care, oil, propane, food, cable, internet, phones, etc., oh yeah I forgot CIGARS!

Taking all of the rest of life's expenses into consideration (even for a poor, starving college student) I'd hardly call a car "super expensive." If you do it correctly, it's dirt cheap.

Just admit it, you're choice to not own a car is pretty much an "environmental" statement (which is fine) and not really driven by the imagined "costs" you described.

[heftysmokes]

Wait, what?


Cheap car: $1000-3000
Killer Bike: $1000-3000 (of course you can go as low as 50 bucks for a fixer upper on craigslist, dump ~100 into it and you're in for under $200)

Gas:
Cheap car: $75/month (that's low. At $3.55/gallon and 25 mpg, you're looking at driving ~500 miles/month, which is half of what's considered average)
Bike: $0

Oil change:
Cheap car: Do it yourself, ~$15/3 months...or, if you're only driving 500 miles/month, and want to change it every 3k miles, $15/6 months
Bike: $0

Insurance:
Cheap car: 30/month. I'm using what we pay for only liability on our sweet-ass 1996 Plymouth Grand Voyager mini-van. Side note, it's actually more expensive for full coverage on our old cheap bomber of a van than it is for full coverage on our 2011 Cruze or our 2005 Tahoe. Reason being, newer vehicles have way higher safety ratings, so medical costs in an accident are way lower.
Bike:$0

CAR:
Gas (900) + Oil (60) + Insurance (360) comes to ~$1320/year operating cost. That doesn't include tires, air filters, belts, beaded seat covers, as well as parking meters/garages, toll booths, etc.


Bike:
Tubes, tires, lube ~75 year. Throw in another 50 for the occasional bus pass and your still looking at 10% of the cost of car ownership.


So while it may very well be his " choice to not own a car is pretty much an "environmental" statement," the costs are definitely not "imagined."

[CoventryCat86]

So while it may very well be his " choice to not own a car is pretty much an "environmental" statement," the costs are definitely not "imagined."

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

$1,320.00 a year for total costs is dirt cheap. My property taxes are over six times that for a year, my electric bill is three times that for a year, my internet/cable bill is exactly that for a year. Even with no job, my federal income tax bill is twice that for a year. Heating oil? How much do you pay? Honestly, this year, I have no idea what my total cost will be for the season but I just paid over three fucking fifty a gallon which means the minimum 200 gallon delivery was over 700.00 and I'll be lucky if that lasts me until the end of December. So if I could heat my house for $1,320.00 (your yearly car cost) I'd throw a party, invite you, pay for your plane fare and still have money left over.

The bottom line is his personal choice to forgo a car isn't because it's "super expensive, even if the car is paid off" because that's bull$hit.

Oh I forgot, I don't even have a mortgage but I'd be willing to bet an average rent or mortgage payment is $1,320.00 per MONTH meaning that the expense of a car is one twelfth of the simple cost of putting a roof over your head, excluding every other cost associated with just breathing.

[JiveTurkey]

Wait, what?


Cheap car: $1000-3000
Killer Bike: $1000-3000 (of course you can go as low as 50 bucks for a fixer upper on craigslist, dump ~100 into it and you're in for under $200)

Gas:
Cheap car: $75/month (that's low. At $3.55/gallon and 25 mpg, you're looking at driving ~500 miles/month, which is half of what's considered average)
Bike: $0

Oil change:
Cheap car: Do it yourself, ~$15/3 months...or, if you're only driving 500 miles/month, and want to change it every 3k miles, $15/6 months
Bike: $0

Insurance:
Cheap car: 30/month. I'm using what we pay for only liability on our sweet-ass 1996 Plymouth Grand Voyager mini-van. Side note, it's actually more expensive for full coverage on our old cheap bomber of a van than it is for full coverage on our 2011 Cruze or our 2005 Tahoe. Reason being, newer vehicles have way higher safety ratings, so medical costs in an accident are way lower.
Bike:$0

CAR:
Gas (900) + Oil (60) + Insurance (360) comes to ~$1320/year operating cost. That doesn't include tires, air filters, belts, beaded seat covers, as well as parking meters/garages, toll booths, etc.


Bike:
Tubes, tires, lube ~75 year. Throw in another 50 for the occasional bus pass and your still looking at 10% of the cost of car ownership.


So while it may very well be his " choice to not own a car is pretty much an "environmental" statement," the costs are definitely not "imagined."

Don't forget to add in the $2 lighter impulse buy at the gas station.

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

$1,320.00 a year for total costs is dirt cheap. My property taxes are over six times that for a year, my electric bill is three times that for a year, my internet/cable bill is exactly that for a year. Even with no job, my federal income tax bill is twice that for a year. Heating oil? How much do you pay? Honestly, this year, I have no idea what my total cost will be for the season but I just paid over three fucking fifty a gallon which means the minimum 200 gallon delivery was over 700.00 and I'll be lucky if that lasts me until the end of December. So if I could heat my house for $1,320.00 (your yearly car cost) I'd throw a party, invite you, pay for your plane fare and still have money left over.

The bottom line is his personal choice to forgo a car isn't because it's "super expensive, even if the car is paid off" because that's bull$hit.

Maybe the word "super" in super expensive is debatable, but it is more expensive to own a car than not. Those expenses go towards other things I care more about. Going green often costs more; this is an example where it costs less. Going car-free is good for MY wallet and the environment--there's nothing bullshit about that. Your values, needs, circumstances differ than mine. I've found something that works well for me.

[heftysmokes]

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

$1,320.00 a year for total costs is dirt cheap. My property taxes are over six times that for a year, my electric bill is three times that for a year, my internet/cable bill is exactly that for a year. Even with no job, my federal income tax bill is twice that for a year. Heating oil? How much do you pay? Honestly, this year, I have no idea what my total cost will be for the season but I just paid over three fucking fifty a gallon which means the minimum 200 gallon delivery was over 700.00 and I'll be lucky if that lasts me until the end of December. So if I could heat my house for $1,320.00 (your yearly car cost) I'd throw a party, invite you, pay for your plane fare and still have money left over.

The bottom line is his personal choice to forgo a car isn't because it's "super expensive, even if the car is paid off" because that's bull$hit.

I totally agree. $1300 for a year of operating a car is indeed dirt cheap. Actually, probably pretty much impossible. The problem with your argument is you're comparing the cost of car ownership to other expenses in your life that are necessities, not to the cost of owning just a bike. So, if you don't "have" to own a bike (which he obviously doesn't) $1300/year is a pretty expensive luxury.
You HAVE TO have heat (btw, our natural gas bill averages about 30/month since you asked), electricity, pay your taxes, etc. You (in this case I'm referring to jiveturkey) don't HAVE TO pay for a car.

Edit for your edit: Once again you're comparing car ownership to cost of living (rent/mortgage), not car ownership to bike ownership.

[CoventryCat86]

Ya know what? Cable and internet is super expensive even if your televisions and computers are paid for. Fug it, I'm calling the cable company right now, disconnecting my cable tv service and to hell with Al Gore's interweb, who needs it? Tomorrow, I'll take all my televisions and computers to the "environmentally safe" recycling center and feel good about myself that I've saved the world!

Am I "cool" now too?

[heftysmokes]

What are you talking about? You said he's imagining the costs he described. I simply pointed out the costs of owning a car aren't imagined.

[CoventryCat86]

What are you talking about? You said he's imagining the costs he described. I simply pointed out the costs of owning a car aren't imagined.

What I'm "talking about" is exactly what I said:

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

When he claims that car ownership is "super expensive, even if the car is paid off" I'm calling that "imagined" because even he now admits this as he backpedaled and stated this

super expensive is debatable

I'm not saying there is no cost associated with car ownership but calling it "super expensive" is fuggen BULLSHIT and that's not debatable.

[CoventryCat86]

Two members of the Corvallis city council are members of the Green Party.[

Hell, even in ultra-liberal Connecticut, we're not that far off the deep end. I live one town over from the "Corvallis" of Connecticut otherwise known as "Storrs" the section of the town of Mansfield where UCONN is located. Mansfield is the most ultra left wing town in the entire eastern half of Connecticut and there aren't any Green Party people on the Town Council there. Storrs' population is only about 1/3 of Corvallis so even the libs can't get away without owning cars.

I guess the average Corvallis mind-set is simply one I just can't relate to........

[badwhale]

My friend's wife has lived in Wilmington & Philadelphia for all her life, and about (I'm going to guess here) hasn't owned a car in about 10 years.

Granted, he has a Jeep for stuff, and they've used the "share a car" thing that people do around the city, but it never blew my mind that someone can operate in a city without a vehicle.

Right, a high percentage of Americans need to have a car to survive and a smaller percentage actually maintain their own vehicles. Wrong, that the main reason Jive doesn't have one is to go "green." The first "pro" to not owning a car to me would be savings on wearable parts, the TIME it takes to work on shit (believe me, unless you have a dedicated shop with a nice rollback of tools and a lift, everything is a PITA), the savings on insurance, the savings on gas, storage etc.

I too usually buy used and do as much maintenance to keep the $/mile down but even recently I've had work done at the shop to save time and aggravation.

Bottom line, if I lived in a city, I would probably shitcan the vehicle if I could, and the first thing I'd do is spend that extra $$ on cigars.

Will

[badwhale]

Weren't we talking about meth lighters & paraphernalia?

[ashauler]

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

$1,320.00 a year for total costs is dirt cheap. My property taxes are over six times that for a year, my electric bill is three times that for a year, my internet/cable bill is exactly that for a year. Even with no job, my federal income tax bill is twice that for a year. Heating oil? How much do you pay? Honestly, this year, I have no idea what my total cost will be for the season but I just paid over three fucking fifty a gallon which means the minimum 200 gallon delivery was over 700.00 and I'll be lucky if that lasts me until the end of December. So if I could heat my house for $1,320.00 (your yearly car cost) I'd throw a party, invite you, pay for your plane fare and still have money left over.

The bottom line is his personal choice to forgo a car isn't because it's "super expensive, even if the car is paid off" because that's bull$hit.

Oh I forgot, I don't even have a mortgage but I'd be willing to bet an average rent or mortgage payment is $1,320.00 per MONTH meaning that the expense of a car is one twelfth of the simple cost of putting a roof over your head, excluding every other cost associated with just breathing.

No, I would think it's his perception, not his imagination.

You're not really trying to tell jiveturkey why he feels as he does are you?

[heftysmokes]

When he said they were "super expensive" that's "imagined" because it is.

--I agree.

Just admit it, you're choice to not own a car is pretty much an "environmental" statement (which is fine) and not really driven by the imagined "costs" you described.

--This is the statement I was refuting. All I was saying is the costs of owning a car are not imagined and they're huge compared to our resident dirty hippie riding his bike everywhere . I wasn't saying a car is cheap compared to a mortgage payment or property taxes or heating oil. I was saying a bike is cheap compared to a car.