Montecruz, Cohiba, Montecristo

[bigpoppapuff]

ultra...so that your offer doesn't smell of spam...tell us a bit more about yourself....your dads interest in cigars,etc etc.....i'll take the kinder,gentler approach and hope you're sincere...if so,there could be some interest in your dads' cigars...

[ultramerican]

ultra...so that your offer doesn't smell of spam...tell us a bit more about yourself....your dads interest in cigars,etc etc.....i'll take the kinder,gentler approach and hope you're sincere...if so,there could be some interest in your dads' cigars...

Thanks a lot. These were stored at Dunhill in New York. They just closed the humidor there and they sent all my father's cigars to his home.

I don't want to identify myself on this board because I don't know who's reading it. I tried to sell them a while back at another forum, but it brought out a lot of hostility from the users there. I'd be happy to email anyone with a sincere interest in these or who has any good ideas for me.

[ggiese]

Thanks a lot. These were stored at Dunhill in New York. They just closed the humidor there and they sent all my father's cigars to his home.

I don't want to identify myself on this board because I don't know who's reading it. I tried to sell them a while back at another forum, but it brought out a lot of hostility from the users there. I'd be happy to email anyone with a sincere interest in these or who has any good ideas for me.

You've already been through this on another board and you came back for seconds???

I can understand ignorance, but this is now sheer folly....


Hey, Shag - great catch in quoting his post. This guy sounds suspiciously like Backdrifter from CP a while back, who deleted all of his posts after he was told it was bad form to sell cigars in his first post.

There was some very wise and frank discussions about what it is you have - and I think you should have probably heeded advice, rather than taking offense to what was said...

[ggiese]

Mr. UltraAmerican - I think the thing you may have missed is this board consists of a group of individuals that all share the same passion - cigars. We love to discuss them, we love to buy them, we love to trade them, we love to smoke them. With that in mind, it is a "brotherhood" of sorts - hence, the BOTL (Brotherhood of the Leaf).

That being said, this group of individuals is highly protective of each other. A new person walking into the situation would not understand it because it defies the norms of society. But, if you stick around, you will find a great group of generous people, who look out for each others interests. No one on this board, especialy the members that have been around for a while, will tolerate anyone attempting to take advantage of the others on the board. That is the backlash you are feeling.

If you're walking in here for the purpose of selling your cigars, you have already been told how to go about that. Instead of flaming the board, maybe you should become a part of the community and take advantage of the knowledge of some of the members of this board. From the sounds of what you have, I doubt seriously you're going to get any kind of serious offer on any of the auction sites - and you certainly can't just create a web page to sell them. It makes sense that you would come to a place like Cigar Smokers because the greatest chance of hooking up with someone who may be interested in your cigars lies here. As an added bouns, there are members on this board that can tell you what those cigars are worth, and where and how to sell them. Whether you realize it or not, You've actually come to the right place to sell your cigars.

You choose to come in here like a bull in a china shop. It's very much like walking into a cocktail party of people you don't know and opening up a briefcase trying to sell your cigars. You're going to get tossed out on your butt. That is just not socially acceptable.

There are quite a few cigars boards on the net - you'll find them all over the place. But I gotta tell you - every one will greet you with the same suspicion, and will be as defensive as this one. If you think it's just limited to this board - I'm afraid you're sadly mistaken.

So - either learn how to act socially in an on-line cigar community, or pack you're briefcase and walk out the door before you find yourself being tossed like a door to door salesman...


Quoted from a post to Mr. Backdrifter - Aug 14 2005, 10:56 AM

[ggiese]

VERY wise advice from someone (MattR) who WOULD know what the cigars are worth...

The Cohiba line was not produced in any shape or form until 1978 and that was in a very limited and not for sale quantity, in Cuba. In 1982 the line became available for sale, in Cuba. The non-Cuban Cohiba brands were introduced in 1990-91. The only Cohiba Triangulare I know of is the Red Dot Cohibas. These were not produced until the late 1990's.

As for the other brands listed. If they are indeed from the 60s or 70's they are worth far more than what is being asked. It would be more worth your father's time to contact Christie's auction house in the UK.

Post some pictures here of the boxes so we can actually see what is being sold.

As for the Dunhill shop, it is at 57th and Park Ave. in New York, but they will not be showing anyone else's cigars to anyone without prior permission.

[ultramerican]

Hi, ggiese.

You found that old thread, I see. I tried to learn from the experience, I hope you can tell. It is true that the Cohiba and the Montecristo aren't as old as the others.

I realize this probably won't work here, but I thought it was worth a shot. Try to look at it from my point of view. I don't know much about the subject, but I'm trying to help my dad because he's not up to dealing with this anymore. The cigars are too valuable to just give away. I just want to find the best solution for our situation.

I'm in the Washington, DC area. I would be happy to meet any interested individuals in person.

I am glad to have the opportunity to use this board.

[Cigar Penguin]

I am surprised dad has no contacts of his own like the shop owners where he kept them,or the shops patrons.How about friends he smoked with or collected with.
I am sure,being in NYC,dunhill staff can direct you,or someone else in nyc,to an appraiser of some sorts to better see what it is you have.Other than that,if you are willing to let someone meet up and have a look at what you have I dont know what else to say,other than make a creative ad and hit ebay up.I'd meet with you but I am inexperianced on old stock.

What you didnt learn from CP was that you didnt get personable with us.You need to gain some trust.I dont see how you didnt catch that the first time around,there were no hidden puzzles on what to do and what not to do.I can save you more grief,you can expect the same results on any one of the hundred or so cigar forums on the net.Now,you can make up your wrong doings or continue on with the same results,its up to you.


How are these cigars being stored now and at what conditions?